Nominations Queries #1

[ashling]

There are some nominations lingering unapproved. If your nomination is listed below, please have a look! Some of these nominations need to be changed or reformatted and others need more information before we can approve them.

RESOLVED - Among The Few - Foyle's War [SAFETY]

This appears to be an episode that is in the middle of a long, continuous television show. Unlike an episode of an anthology show, or the first episode of a series that could stand on this own, this does not appear to qualify to be a safety fandom. Please provide more information or change to Foyle’s War (TV).

RESOLVED - Creator's Choice of Fandom

The nominations guidelines state that this fandom will not be in the tagset. Please remove it from your nominations.

RESOLVED - Lavender Laboratories (Visual Novel) [SAFETY]

We are having some trouble finding out how long it takes to consume this canon. Could you please direct us to some information that would help us determine that it’s a safety fandom?

RESOLVED - Over the Garden Wall (Cartoon & Comics) [SAFETY]

Over the Garden Wall (Cartoon) [SAFETY] would work. Over the Garden Wall (Cartoon & Comics) would also work. Which would you prefer?

RESOLVED - Paintings - James Christensen [SAFETY]

The current formatting does not go with nominations guidelines. “Six Bird Hunters in Full Camouflage - James Christensen” for fandom and “Worldbuilding & None (6 Bird Hunters)” for relationship would work, can we change it to that?

RESOLVED - Star Wars: A New Hope [SAFETY]

With pairing Obi-Wan Kenobi/Anakin Skywalker (Star Wars: A New Hope [Safety]). Tagmods have some concerns that this movie could not be taken as a standalone and is not in the spirit of a safety fandom. We prefer not to reject, however, as this uses up a fandom slot you could use to nominate something else. Please edit or provide more information.

As always, if you see any mistakes in the tagset, do let us know 💛

Comments

[coaldustcanary]

Small typo under Game of Thrones:

Jaime Lanniste/Brienne of Tarth (GOT)

should be

Jaime Lannister/Brienne of Tarth (GOT)

[ashling]

fixed, thanks! 💛

[lamiacalls]

I'd prefer Over the Garden Wall (Cartoon) [SAFETY] please!

(Also apologies for nominating Bridgerton as a safety; I took google at face value and had somehow forgotten that each episode was an hour so 72 mins for an entire runtime wouldn't make sense! Maths is not my strong suit orz)

[ashling]

No problem! Over the Garden Wall (Cartoon) [SAFETY] should be in there now 💛

[fleetsparrow]

I was in the fence about it being a safety, but each episode of Foyle's War (at least, in the beginning) is pretty much a standalone mystery, and one nominated character exists only in that episode, so his arc (for example) is completely self-contained. I could go either way on it, though, so just let me know and I'll change it.

[ashling]

Please change it, thanks 💛

[fleetsparrow]

Changed! <3

[ashling]

Approved! 💛

Star Wars: A New Hope [SAFETY]

[(Anonymous)]

I nominated Star Wars: A New Hope as a safety fandom following the example that Iron Man 1 could be nominated as a safety fandom as the first in the series that can be consumed alone. A New Hope has a runtime of only two hours. What's more, A New Hope has a lore that exists standalone as explicitly contradicted by later movies: it's the only movie where Darth Vader and Anakin Skywalker are two separate people. The idea was to have a prompt explicitly asking for something set in this contradicted backstory, which would not require consuming any other part of the franchise.

Re: Star Wars: A New Hope [SAFETY]

[john_burton_lee]

Ugh. This was me. I wish dreamwidth gave some warning about posting when not logged in. As an addendum: I also intended to put in an & relationship and not a / relationship, but I must not have been paying attention when ao3 auto completed things for me.

Re: Star Wars: A New Hope [SAFETY]

[ashling]

Approved! Also I am editing in an & version right now 💛

Re: Star Wars: A New Hope [SAFETY]

[ashling]

Star Wars: A New Hope [SAFETY] has been approved! Thanks 💛

[muccamukk]

Loki/Thor (MCU) has sneaked into Marvel 616. That's Loki for you.

I'm not sure if this is a duplicate, or different media versions: in uncategorised fandoms:

The Henna Wars - Adiba Jaigirdar (1) ↓
The Henna Wars [SAFETY] (0)

[event_kosch]

That's a duplicate, there's only the book
The question is, did ao3 glitch or did the mods decide it's not a safety? I definitively nominated The Henna Wars [SAFETY], but in approved list it shows The Henna Wars - Adiba Jaigirdar

[ashling]

Hi! Sorry about that, there was a bug that made it so that even when we had changed a fandom tag, both the original nominated tag and the approved fandom tag showed up.

Re: the Henna Wars, that is not considered a safety fandom
https://howlongtoread.com/books/2221922/The-Henna-Wars

If you have additional information about the wordcount length of The Henna Wars that we're missing, we'd be happy to look at it 💛

[ashling]

oh Loki 😂 dealing w him is like herding cats! he should be in the right place now, hopefully he'll stay there (and Thor along with him)

and the Henna Wars one should be fixed too now, thanks for letting us know!💛

[graveexcitement]

Noticed a duplicate (or perhaps a variant? 🤔):

Loki (TV 2021) [SAFETY] (6)
loki (tv) [safety] (0)

Not sure if this one is a duplicate or if they're distinct (also, both have misspelled "SAFETY" as "SAFTEY," though that's probably not an issue):

Queen B (Visual Novel) [SAFTEY] (0)
Queen B: Book 1 (Visual Novel) [SAFTEY] (4)

[ashling]

variant, heheheheheh

those should be fixed now, thanks! 💛

[(Anonymous)]

A couple of duplicates.

In Assassin's Creed - All Media Types you have both "M!Eivor/Sigurd Styrbjornson" and "Male Eivor/Sigurd Styrbjornson (Assassin's Creed)", and also "Alexios (Assassin's Creed)/Brasidas (d. 422 BCE)" and "Alexios/Brasidas (Assassin's Creed)". The latter of each pair is probably the one that should stay.

[ashling]

Fixed, thank you! <3

[(Anonymous)]

More duplicates:

Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008) - All Media Types
CC-2224 | Cody/Obi-Wan Kenobi (SWTCW)
Cody/Obi-Wan Kenobi (SW:TCW)

Pride and Prejudice - Jane Austen
Elizabeth Bennet/Fitzwilliam Darcy (P&P - Austen)
Elizabeth Bennet/Fitzwilliam Darcy (Pride and Prejudice - Jane Austen)
Georgiana Darcy & None (P&P - Austen)
Georgiana Darcy & None (Pride and Prejudice - Jane Austen)

[ashling]

Fixed, thank you! <3

[(Anonymous)]

More duplicates:

Yu-Gi-Oh! Duel Monsters (Anime & Manga)
Kaiba Seto/Mutou Yuugi (YGO - DM)
Kaiba Seto/Mutou Yuugi (YGO DM)

Marvel Cinematic Universe
Steve Rogers/Tony Stark (Marvel Cinematic Universe)
Steve Rogers/Tony Stark (MCU)

The Defenders (Marvel TV)
Frank Castle & Billy Russo (Defenders)
Frank Castle & Billy Russo (The Defenders)

琅琊榜 | Nirvana in Fire (TV)
Mu Nihuang & Mu Qing (Nirvana in Fire)
Mu Qing & Mu Nihuang (Nirvana in Fire)

Legend of the Galactic Heroes - Die Neue These
Jessica Edwards/Jean Robert Lappe/Yang Wenli (Die Neue These)
Jessica Edwards/Jean Robert Lappe/Yang Wenli (LoGH - DNT)
Yang Wenli & None (Die Neue These)
Yang Wenli & None (LoGH - DNT)

DCU (Comics)
Alfred Pennyworth & None (DCU (Comics))
Alfred Pennyworth & None (DCU Comics)

Star Trek: The Original Series
James T. Kirk/Leonard "Bones" McCoy/Spock (ST: TOS)
James T. Kirk/Leonard "Bones" McCoy/Spock (Star Trek: The Original Series)
Leonard "Bones" McCoy/Spock (ST: TOS)
Leonard "Bones" McCoy/Spock (Star Trek: The Original Series)

Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling
Worldbuilding & None (Harry Potter - J.K. Rowling)
Worldbuilding & None (Harry Potter - JKR)

The following are in Loki (TV 2021) [SAFETY] AND Marvel Cinematic Universe:
Alligator Loki & Kid Loki (Loki TV)
Classic Loki & Kid Loki (Loki TV)
Hunter B-15/Sylvie (Loki TV)
Loki & Classic Loki (Loki TV)
Loki & Kid Loki (Loki TV)
Loki/Mobius M. Mobius/Sylvie (Loki TV)
Loki/Sylvie (Loki TV)
Mobius M. Mobius & Sylvie (Loki TV)

This one is in both Crossover Fandom and Marvel Cinematic Universe:
Loki (Marvel)/Lucifer Morningstar (Lucifer TV)

And Loki/Thor (MCU) is unfortunately still in Marvel 616 and Avengers Academy (Video Game) as well as MCU.

[ashling]

Should be fixed now! After a mighty battle with the army of Lokis. Thank you very much for your eye for detail, that helps us a lot 💛

[(Anonymous)]

Star Trek (2009) [SAFETY]

Jaylah & Nyota Uhura (Star Trek (2009)
Jaylah/James T. Kirk (Star Trek (2009)

Jaylah doesn't appear in Star Trek 2009.

[ashling]

Thanks! Moving those to Star Trek: Alternate Original Series (Movies) as that seems to be the proper place for them